Tag Archives: Nietzsche

Philosophy matters: Socrates versus Nietzsche

Meditations of a 21st century incarnation of Socrates as composed by Brent Silby

Greetings my friends,
I found the above image on a social media page named “Philosophy Matters”. Now, from what I understand, Nietzsche did indeed call me ugly. But more to the point, he did not agree with my methodology. This disagreement, he expressed, in a fashion that differs from my own point-to-point logic. Perhaps referral to my appearance was metaphorical, or rhetorical — a way to underpin his thoughts about my philosophy. Or perhaps it is what people call an ad-hominem attack.

Would I tell Nietzsche his life is not worth living, even if examined? By the gods, I do not know. It is unlikely he would allow me to examine his life in my usual way — the purpose of which is to help one focus less on bodily desires and more on reason in order to tend to one’s soul and do what’s right, which is the road to happiness. Nietzsche disagreed with this, so it is possible that I may conclude that his life is not worth living.

Back to the image. I wonder why this was posted on “Philosophy Matters” with no accompanying text. It does not look like love of wisdom to me. If philosophy does indeed matter, should we not represent it accurately? Then again, perhaps it is just a joke.

— Socrates

Filed under Articles, Socrates' Meditations

Nietzsche’s Birthday

Today is Nietzsche’s birthday. He wasn’t a big fan of my work. He even committed an ad hominem attack against me in his Twilight of the Idols. He tried to refute me by referring to my appearance, calling me the “lowest of the low” because of the way I look. It is true that I am not the most beautiful person on the exterior. But, as I always reminded people, the mere appearance of beauty is not necessarily the same as real beauty. That can only be found in the soul. I would, by extension, suggest that the external appearance of ugliness doesn’t reflect the true nature of the person.

Nietzsche didn’t approve of my approach to philosophy. He thought dialogue was nothing more than cheap entertainment, and he disagreed with my reasoned approach to life–specifically my arguments about how to attain happiness through virtue.

It is a shame I never had the opportunity to engage in dialogue with Nietzsche. I would very much like to examine his thoughts…even if he thinks the elenchus method is cheap entertainment.
— Socrates

Filed under Socrates' Meditations